Thursday’s Bust – What Went Wrong?

All the ingredients seemed to be lining up for a significant severe weather event, particularly in western Connecticut and adjacent parts of New York. What did we see? Sporadic damage reports and a dying squall line that moved out of the Poconos.

There was certainly a  lot of potential on Thursday. Models had been showing moderate amounts of instability and very strong shear. Forecast and observed hodographs indicated the potential for tornadoes in any discrete cells that developed or along squall lines.

18z NAM 6 hour HVN 0-3km hodograph forecast

While deep layer (and low level) shear was sufficient for supercells a strong cap near 850mb prevented convection from developing ahead of the main line. Here’s a 23z RAP sounding (initialization) for HVN and you can see right off the bat the problem.

Yikes!!! That’s a lot of CIN. The LFC is nearly 775mb with a large negative area on that sounding. While the squall line looked exceptionally impressive over Pennsylvania it began to fizzle as it worked east. The large amount of convective inhibition became problematic as the squall line’s cold pool was unable to force surface based parcels to the LFC.

Our models had shown that the CIN present during the day would weaken but apparently that was not the case. While low level moistening helped eliminate some of the negative area it was not enough. The cap was also quite low. Typically we see caps around 700 mb… not 850mb! The exceptional warm 850mb temperatures (over +22c) effectively served to cap convection.

With a convective temperature of 95F we just weren’t going to get rid of that CIN. The warm layer at 850mb (NAM did do well with this) was just too much. With stronger surface heating and more low level moistening things may have been different.

The storms were most certainly a bust. The Storm Prediction Center issued the first ever (that I can remember) day 2 moderate risk for Connecticut. The probabilities for severe wind and significant severe were some of the highest you’ll ever see in Connecticut.  In fact while the event was ongoing the SPC sent out a discussion saying they contemplated an upgrade to “high risk” which would have been the first time since May 31, 1998 parts of the state have been in a high risk! As the squall line was leaving the Poconos the SPC expected the storm to strengthen and called it a derecho.

In the end a lack of synoptic forecasting (500mb heights were neutral from 18z-00z) and strong CIN thanks to a stout low level cap did our severe chances in. Given the potential it was important to mention the possibilities. Severe weather is a challenge to forecast – certainly much more challenging than a winter snowstorm!

Significant Severe Weather Threat Later Today

1630z SWODY1

After two bouts of severe weather last night with a spectacular lightning display, gusty winds, and large hail in Litchfield County the real show may not be until later today.

The Storm Prediction Center has upgraded portions of southern New England to a “moderate risk” which means a 45% chance or greater likelihood of severe weather within 25 miles of any given point.

Much like last Wednesday (during the Hampden County tornado) the instability in the atmosphere is extreme. When CAPE exceeds 3000 j/kg instability is high when it exceeds 5000 j/kg it’s extreme and that’s what is in place just to our west thanks to high dew points and a remnant elevated mixed layer aloft.

16z SBCAPE (Courtesy: SPC Mesoanalysis)

Though there will be moderate to strong shear in the atmosphere capable of producing rotating updrafts (and subsequently large hail) the tornado threat is low. The wind shear today is mostly speed shear as opposed to directional shear. Last Wednesday winds turned rapidly with height (directional shear) which is favorable for tornadoes particularly when that change happens in the lowest mile or two of the atmosphere.

Today’s severe weather event will likely bring an organized squall line capable of producing destructive winds. Out ahead of the squall line any storms that organize will be capable of producing large hail and potential a brief/isolated tornado but nothing like last Wednesday.

12z NAM 6 Hour Forecast 500mb Heights and Vorticity

The atmosphere will remain capped until 2 or 3 p.m. and then we’ll see things explode to our northwest. The cap will be weakened as a disturbance moves in from the west resulting in large-scale ascent. As 500 mb heights fall you generally see the removal convective inhibition (known as CIN and pronounced “sin”)  and thunderstorms start to fire.

I expect the significant severe weather threat to exist down to the Connecticut shoreline today as well. These are the kinds of events that pose a severe weather risk for the entire state.